2. 116 Mill St Buffalo NY
116 Mill St Buffalo NY

Report Results for

116 Mill St Buffalo, NY

116 Mill St Buffalo, NY 14221 was built in 1875 and last sold for $430,000. The property has a lot size of 7,560 Sq Ft lot and is listed as a Single Family. The property is currently not for sale. Current estimates place the value near 496,000, reflecting a -1% change over the past year, with 4 beds, 1.5 baths, and approximately 2,125 sq ft of living space. If you are looking to buy or rent a property, use USPhoneBook's property database to avoid rental scams, understand tax liabilities, and get a sense of the property's value over time. You can also check out the neighborhood section and see nearby homes, last sold for prices, tax records and more.
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Public Facts

$430,000
Last sold Sep 11, 2025
4
Beds
1.5
Baths
2,125
Sqft
Off Market
$496,000 estimated value
Built in 1875
$233/sqft
7,560 lot sqft
$277 HOA fees

Property characteristics

Property type
Residential
Zoning type
Single Family
APN
142201 69.17-2-6
Parking
2
Subdivision
Holland Land Companys Survey
Heating
Central
Cooling
Central
Stories
2

Property History

Over the last 12 months, the sales price of 116 Mill St Buffalo, NY 14221 has decreased by -1%, and the tax decreased by -69%.

Price History

Expand
Collapse
Year Price Price/Sq Ft
2026 $ 484,000 -1 % $ 228
2025 $ 491,000 24 % $ 231
2024 $ 395,000 7 % $ 186
2023 $ 368,000 9 % $ 173
2022 $ 335,000 13 % $ 158
2021 $ 296,000 ---- $ 139

Tax History

Expand
Collapse
Year Taxes Assesments
2025 $ 3,258 -69 % $ 430,000
2024 $ 10,730 ---- $ 430,000
2023 ---- $ 272,500
2022 $ 8,995 ---- $ 250,000
2021 ---- $ 250,000
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Owner

Sarah Pfeister Sarah Q Pfeister , Age 46

Lives at 116 Mill St, Buffalo, NY 14221-5549
Relatives: Richard Pfeister, Margaret Buckley, Timothy Switalski, Brien Pfeister, Darlene Daniels, Eleanor Buckley, Kenneth Buckley, Laura Switalski
View Report

People Living at 116 Mill St Buffalo, NY

Sarah Pfeister Sarah Q Pfeister , Age 46

Lives at 116 Mill St, Buffalo, NY 14221-5549 Buffalo NY 14221 116 Mill St
Prior addresses: 5665 East LN, Lake View, NY 14085-9629 Lake View NY 14085 5665 East LN 94 N Ellicott St, Buffalo, NY 14221-5535 Buffalo NY 14221 94 N Ellicott St 94 N Ellicott St, Williamsville, NY 14221-5535 Williamsville NY 14221 94 N Ellicott St
Relatives: Richard Pfeister, Margaret Buckley, Timothy Switalski, Brien Pfeister, Darlene Daniels, Eleanor Buckley, Kenneth Buckley, Laura Switalski
View Report

Hoyt Leonhardt Hoyt L Leonhardt , Age 44

Lives at 2227 Delwood Ave, Durango, CO 81301-4826 Durango CO 81301 2227 Delwood Ave
Prior addresses: 2408 Thomas AVE, Durango, CO 81301-4520 Durango CO 81301 2408 Thomas AVE 116 Mill St, Buffalo, NY 14221-5549 Buffalo NY 14221 116 Mill St 116 Mill St, Williamsville, NY 14221-5549 Williamsville NY 14221 116 Mill St
Relatives: Lawrence Leonhardt, Louanne Leonhardt, Margo Leonhardt, Rhiannon Leonhardt, Calvin Rackl, Claire Te, Elizabeth Rackl, Harwood Living, Jacob Collins
View Report

Catherine Bailey Catherine A Bailey , Age 28

Lives at 116 Mill Rd, Buffalo, NY 14224-4127 Buffalo NY 14224 116 Mill Rd
Prior addresses: 9 Little Ln, Buffalo, NY 14227-1327 Buffalo NY 14227 9 Little Ln
Relatives: David Bailey, Krystal Bailey, Sheila Bailey, Janet Bailey, Laurie Vega, Megan Alverio, Sheila Pozantidis, Alexander Pozantidis
View Report

Zachary Izzo Zachary B Izzo , Age 29

Lives at 116 Mill RD, West Seneca, NY 14224-4127 West Seneca NY 14224 116 Mill RD
Prior addresses: 116 Mill Rd, Buffalo, NY 14224-4127 Buffalo NY 14224 116 Mill Rd 223 Fruitwood Ter, Buffalo, NY 14221-4744 Buffalo NY 14221 223 Fruitwood Ter
Relatives: Joel Izzo, Rachel Izzo, Zach Izzo, Eugene Buell, Mary Buell, Charles Buell
View Report

Rhiannon Leonhardt Rhiannon Eve Leonhardt , Age 46

Lives at 4650 Christian Dr, Clarence, NY 14031-1803 Clarence NY 14031 4650 Christian Dr
Prior addresses: 2227 Delwood Ave, Durango, CO 81301-4826 Durango CO 81301 2227 Delwood Ave 2408 Thomas Ave, Durango, CO 81301-4520 Durango CO 81301 2408 Thomas Ave 116 Mill ST, Amherst, NY 14221-5549 Amherst NY 14221 116 Mill ST
Relatives: Calvin Rackl, Elizabeth Rackl, Hoyt E, Jacob Collins, Karen Economou, Lawrence Leonhardt, Mary Collins, Marybeth Dabb, Rosemary Pierce
View Report

Richard Pfeister Richard Pfeister , Age 77

Lives at 116 Mill St, Buffalo, NY 14221-5549 Buffalo NY 14221 116 Mill St
Prior addresses: 2938 Otterdam Rd, Waverly, VA 23890-4821 Waverly VA 23890 2938 Otterdam Rd 1968 Jewel St, Johns Island, SC 29455-8175 Johns Island SC 29455 1968 Jewel St
Relatives: Sarah Pfeister, Brien Pfeister, Darlene Daniels, Patricia Pfeister, Richard Pfeister, Bruce Daniels, Edward Mcdaniels, Jill Daniels, Lindsay Pfeister
View Report

Eric Agron Eric M Agron , Age 38

Lives at 5553 Lake Ave, Orchard Park, NY 14127-1121 Orchard Park NY 14127 5553 Lake Ave
Prior addresses: 116 Mill Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224-4127 West Seneca NY 14224 116 Mill Rd 61 1/2 Delevan Ave, Delevan, NY 14042-9610 Delevan NY 14042 61 1/2 Delevan Ave 2124 Perry Rd, North Java, NY 14113-9728 North Java NY 14113 2124 Perry Rd
Relatives: Claudia Agron, Diego Agron
View Report

Karl Mehnert Karl J Mehnert , Age 85

Lives at 3890 Vista Campana S, Unit 94, Oceanside, CA 92057-8160 Oceanside CA 92057 3890 Vista Campana S, Unit 94
Prior addresses: Po Box 216, Irving, NY 14081-0216 Irving NY 14081 Po Box 216 116 Mill St, Amherst, NY 14221-5549 Amherst NY 14221 116 Mill St 116 Mill St, Williamsville, NY 14221-5549 Williamsville NY 14221 116 Mill St
Relatives: Joanna Mehnert, Elizabeth Mehnert, Robert Mehnert, Ashlyn Mehnert, Barbara Williams, Carole Gruschow, Colleen Dudek, Deborah Cassel
View Report

Joanna Mehnert Joanna M Mehnert , Age 77

Lives at 116 Mill St, Amherst, NY 14221-5549 Amherst NY 14221 116 Mill St
Prior addresses: 216 PO Box, Irving, NY 14081-0216 Irving NY 14081 216 PO Box 3890 Vista Campana S, Unit 94, Oceanside, CA 92057-8160 Oceanside CA 92057 3890 Vista Campana S, Unit 94
Relatives: Karl Mehnert, Elizabeth Mehnert, Robert Mehnert, Ashlyn Mehnert, Barbara Williams, Carole Gruschow, Colleen Dudek, Deborah Cassel
View Report

Jacqueline Rosa Jacqueline M Rosa , Age 34

Lives at 28 Fairlawn Dr, East Aurora, NY 14052-2225 East Aurora NY 14052 28 Fairlawn Dr
Prior addresses: 116 Mill Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224-4127 West Seneca NY 14224 116 Mill Rd 116 Mill Rd, Buffalo, NY 14224-4127 Buffalo NY 14224 116 Mill Rd 6519 Olean Rd, South Wales, NY 14139-9791 South Wales NY 14139 6519 Olean Rd
Relatives: Brianna Drummer, Deborah Rosa, Gabriel Rosa, Max Easton, Antonio Larosa, Cleon Easton, Cleon Dr, Doreen Tober, Gilberto Rosa
View Report


Neighbors

120 Mill St
Buffalo, NY
View Property Report
110 Mill St
Buffalo, NY
View Property Report
102 Mill St
Buffalo, NY
View Property Report
115 Mill St
Buffalo, NY
View Property Report

FAQs

Who lives at 116 Mill St, Buffalo, NY 14221?
According to our records, the current person living in 116 Mill St is Sarah Pfeister.
Is this property currently for sale?
The property is not for sale and last sold for $430,000 on Sep 11, 2025. Use USPhoneBook to review nearby listings or compare similar homes in the area.
What is the estimated value of this property?
The estimated value is $496,000, reflecting a -1% change over the past year. You can explore price history and tax records to see how the value has changed over time.
How big is this property?
It features approximately 2,125 sq ft of living space on a 7,560 sq ft lot, built in 1875 and classified as a Single Family.
What nearby properties can I compare this to?
Nearby homes include 120 Mill St, 110 Mill St, and 102 Mill St, each with its own property report to help compare size, value, and residents.