2. 12 Sutton Pl Islip NY
12 Sutton Pl Islip NY

Report Results for

12 Sutton Pl Islip, NY

12 Sutton Pl Islip, NY 11751 was built in 1989 and last sold for $725,000. The property has a lot size of 2,178 Sq Ft lot and is listed as a Single Family. The property is currently not for sale. Current estimates place the value near 678,000, reflecting a 3% change over the past year, with 2 beds, 3 baths, and approximately 1,700 sq ft of living space. If you are looking to buy or rent a property, use USPhoneBook's property database to avoid rental scams, understand tax liabilities, and get a sense of the property's value over time. You can also check out the neighborhood section and see nearby homes, last sold for prices, tax records and more.
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Public Facts

$725,000
Last sold May 2, 2025
2
Beds
3
Baths
1,700
Sqft
Off Market
$678,000 estimated value
Built in 1989
$399/sqft
2,178 lot sqft

Property characteristics

Property type
Residential
Zoning type
Single Family
APN
0500-371.01-01.00-006.000
Subdivision
Colony At Holbrook Section 1a

Property History

Over the last 12 months, the sales price of 12 Sutton Pl Islip, NY 11751 has increased by 3%.

Price History

Expand
Collapse
Year Price Price/Sq Ft
2026 $ 676,000 3 % $ 398
2025 $ 651,000 4 % $ 383
2024 $ 624,000 10 % $ 367
2023 $ 563,000 5 % $ 331
2022 $ 532,000 18 % $ 313
2021 $ 449,000 ---- $ 264

Tax History

Expand
Collapse
Year Taxes Assesments
2025 ---- $ 39,000
2024 ---- $ 39,000
2023 ---- $ 39,000
2022 ---- $ 39,000
2021 ---- $ 39,000
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Owner

Catherine Muhlenforth Catherine A Muhlenforth , Age 33

Lives at 340 Alfred St, North Babylon, NY 11703-3502
Relatives: Linda Muhlenforth
View Report

People Living at 12 Sutton Pl Islip, NY

Catherine Muhlenforth Catherine A Muhlenforth , Age 33

Lives at 340 Alfred St, North Babylon, NY 11703-3502 North Babylon NY 11703 340 Alfred St
Prior addresses: 12 Sutton PL, Islip, NY 11751-3720 Islip NY 11751 12 Sutton PL 340 Alfred ST, Babylon, NY 11703-3502 Babylon NY 11703 340 Alfred ST
Relatives: Linda Muhlenforth
View Report

Timothy Finnegan Timothy Emilio Thomas Finnegan , Age 38

Lives at 33 Wave Crest Dr, Islip, NY 11751-4015 Islip NY 11751 33 Wave Crest Dr
Prior addresses: 12 Sutton PL, Islip, NY 11751-3720 Islip NY 11751 12 Sutton PL 16 Willow AVE, Islip, NY 11751-3920 Islip NY 11751 16 Willow AVE 200 Circle Rd, Rm D303, Stony Brook, NY 11790-3401 Stony Brook NY 11790 200 Circle Rd, Rm D303
Relatives: Bryan Finnegan, Elizabeth Finnegan, Robert Finnegan, Barbara Finnegan, Agnes Finnegan, Anne Finnegan, Caroline Williams, Carolynn Finnegan, David Finnegan
View Report

Heather Hellriegel Heather E Hellriegel , Age 53

Lives at 4241 Cross Creek Ct, Apt 306, Raleigh, NC 27607-7552 Raleigh NC 27607 4241 Cross Creek Ct, Apt 306
Prior addresses: 2920 Village DR, Unit 2309, Steamboat Springs, CO 80487-2123 Steamboat Springs CO 80487 2920 Village DR, Unit 2309 12 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751-3720 Islip NY 11751 12 Sutton Pl 24 Charleys Pl, Bay Shore, NY 11706-8072 Bay Shore NY 11706 24 Charleys Pl
Relatives: Alexandra Madej, Caroline Diehl, Jennifer Cantin, Jennifer Madej, Joann Hellriegel, Nicolas Madej, Philip Hellriegel, Valerie Hellriegel, Adam Madej
View Report

James Madej James S Madej , Age 59

Lives at 229 Woodsborough Pl, Raleigh, NC 27601-1557 Raleigh NC 27601 229 Woodsborough Pl
Prior addresses: 4241 Cross Creek Ct, Apt 306, Raleigh, NC 27607-7552 Raleigh NC 27607 4241 Cross Creek Ct, Apt 306 12 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751-3720 Islip NY 11751 12 Sutton Pl
Relatives: Jennifer Madej, Adam Madej, Alexandra Madej, Bette Madej, Ella Madej, Heather Hellriegel, John Madej
View Report

Nicolas Madej Nicolas Joseph Madej , Age 26

Lives at 81 S Williams St, Unit 404, Burlington, VT 05401-3470 Burlington VT 05401 81 S Williams St, Unit 404
Prior addresses: 70 Cambrian Way, Apt 210, Burlington, VT 05401-2996 Burlington VT 05401 70 Cambrian Way, Apt 210 2018 PO Box, South Burlington, VT 05407-2018 South Burlington VT 05407 2018 PO Box 12 Sutton PL, Islip, NY 11751-3720 Islip NY 11751 12 Sutton PL
Relatives: Alexandra Madej, Heather Hellriegel, Jennifer Madej, Adam Madej, Bette Madej, Caroline Diehl, Ella Madej
View Report

Daniel Reuther Daniel W Reuther , Age 95

Lives at 12 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751-3720 Islip NY 11751 12 Sutton Pl
Prior addresses: 318 Reed Farm Rd, Boxborough, MA 01719-1616 Boxborough MA 01719 318 Reed Farm Rd Po Box 5395, Hauppauge, NY 11788-0119 Hauppauge NY 11788 Po Box 5395 103 Paugusett Cir, Trumbull, CT 06611-4575 Trumbull CT 06611 103 Paugusett Cir
Relatives: Ann Reuther, Ashley Reuther, Daniel Reuther, Janet Reuther, Patricia Reuther, Susan Reuther, Thomas Reuther
View Report

Janet Reuther Janet Marie Reuther , Age 64

Lives at 11611 Summer Ave NE, Albuquerque, NM 87112-5654 Albuquerque NM 87112 11611 Summer Ave NE
Prior addresses: 2405 Britt ST NE, Albuquerque, NM 87112-1543 Albuquerque NM 87112 2405 Britt ST NE 12952 Carrie Pl SE, Albuquerque, NM 87123-3804 Albuquerque NM 87123 12952 Carrie Pl SE 534 Alcazar St SE, Apt A, Albuquerque, NM 87108-3904 Albuquerque NM 87108 534 Alcazar St SE, Apt A
Relatives: Ann Reuther, Daniel Reuther, Jessica Taylor, Jewell Reuther, Patricia Reuther, Thomas Reuther
View Report

Leigh Bongiorno Leigh F Bongiorno , Age 59

Lives at 115 Percy Williams Dr, East Islip, NY 11730-2200 East Islip NY 11730 115 Percy Williams Dr
Prior addresses: 20 Gibbons Ct, Sayville, NY 11782-1969 Sayville NY 11782 20 Gibbons Ct 363 Greenbelt Pkwy, Holtsville, NY 11742-2227 Holtsville NY 11742 363 Greenbelt Pkwy
Relatives: Joseph Bongiorno, Adelaide Bongiorno, Bridget Syron, Gabriella Bongiorno, Harriet Syron, Jacquelyn Flieger, Joan Syron, Meredith Alvaro, Michelle Bongiorno
View Report


Neighbors

14 Sutton Pl
Islip, NY
View Property Report
10 Sutton Pl
Islip, NY
View Property Report
16 Sutton Pl
Islip, NY
View Property Report
8 Sutton Pl
Islip, NY
View Property Report

FAQs

Who lives at 12 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751?
According to our records, the current person living in 12 Sutton Pl is Catherine Muhlenforth.
Is this property currently for sale?
The property is not for sale and last sold for $725,000 on May 2, 2025. Use USPhoneBook to review nearby listings or compare similar homes in the area.
What is the estimated value of this property?
The estimated value is $678,000, reflecting a 3% change over the past year. You can explore price history and tax records to see how the value has changed over time.
How big is this property?
It features approximately 1,700 sq ft of living space on a 2,178 sq ft lot, built in 1989 and classified as a Single Family.
What nearby properties can I compare this to?
Nearby homes include 14 Sutton Pl, 10 Sutton Pl, and 16 Sutton Pl, each with its own property report to help compare size, value, and residents.