2. 2 Sutton Pl Islip NY
2 Sutton Pl Islip NY

Report Results for

2 Sutton Pl Islip, NY

2 Sutton Pl Islip, NY 11751 was built in 1992 and last sold for $395,000. The property has a lot size of 3,485 Sq Ft lot and is listed as a Single Family. The property is currently not for sale. Current estimates place the value near 800,000, reflecting a 3% change over the past year, with 3 beds, 2.5 baths, and approximately 2,000 sq ft of living space. If you are looking to buy or rent a property, use USPhoneBook's property database to avoid rental scams, understand tax liabilities, and get a sense of the property's value over time. You can also check out the neighborhood section and see nearby homes, last sold for prices, tax records and more.
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Public Facts

$395,000
Last sold Oct 22, 2025
3
Beds
2.5
Baths
2,000
Sqft
Off Market
$800,000 estimated value
Built in 1992
$400/sqft
3,485 lot sqft
$330 HOA fees

Property characteristics

Property type
Residential
Zoning type
Single Family
APN
0500-371.01-01.00-001.000
Subdivision
Emerald Woods

Property History

Over the last 12 months, the sales price of 2 Sutton Pl Islip, NY 11751 has increased by 3%.

Price History

Expand
Collapse
Year Price Price/Sq Ft
2026 $ 770,000 3 % $ 385
2025 $ 747,000 15 % $ 374
2024 $ 647,000 4 % $ 324
2023 $ 619,000 8 % $ 310
2022 $ 572,000 15 % $ 286
2021 $ 497,000 ---- $ 249

Tax History

Expand
Collapse
Year Taxes Assesments
2025 ---- $ 43,500
2024 ---- $ 43,500
2023 ---- $ 43,500
2022 ---- $ 43,500
2021 ---- $ 43,500
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Owner

Dawn Callaway Dawn M Callaway , Age 58

Lives at 2 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751-3700
Relatives: Carol Ramsey, Dawn Callaway, Diane Darcy, James Callaway, John Ramsey, Lauren Callaway, Robert Callaway
View Report

People Living at 2 Sutton Pl Islip, NY

Dawn Callaway Dawn M Callaway , Age 58

Lives at 2 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751-3700 Islip NY 11751 2 Sutton Pl
Prior addresses: 20 Sutton PL, Islip, NY 11751-3722 Islip NY 11751 20 Sutton PL 4200 Arkansas Ave, Columbus, MS 39705-7506 Columbus MS 39705 4200 Arkansas Ave 1985 1st St W, Unit 2203, Randolph Afb, TX 78150-4328 Randolph Afb TX 78150 1985 1st St W, Unit 2203
Relatives: Carol Ramsey, Dawn Callaway, Diane Darcy, James Callaway, John Ramsey, Lauren Callaway, Robert Callaway
View Report

James Callaway James H Callaway , Age 69

Lives at 2 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751-3700 Islip NY 11751 2 Sutton Pl
Prior addresses: 20 Sutton PL, Islip, NY 11751-3722 Islip NY 11751 20 Sutton PL 4200 Arkansas Ave, Columbus, MS 39705-7506 Columbus MS 39705 4200 Arkansas Ave
Relatives: Barbara Callaway, Dawn Callaway, Diana Callaway, Diana Davis, James Callaway, Lauren Callaway, Mollie Callaway, Robert Callaway
View Report

Robert Callaway Robert Callaway

Lives at 6363 Gulf Winds Dr, Apt 232, St Pete Beach, FL 33706-3752 St Pete Beach FL 33706 6363 Gulf Winds Dr, Apt 232
Prior addresses: 2 Sutton PL, Islip, NY 11751-3700 Islip NY 11751 2 Sutton PL 5461 Windflower RD, Rockford, IL 61107-2447 Rockford IL 61107 5461 Windflower RD
Relatives: Barbara Callaway, Dawn Callaway, James Callaway, Lauren Callaway, Mollie Callaway, Robert Callaway, Carol Ramsey
View Report

Rita Mcloughlin Rita Brock Mcloughlin , Age 60

Lives at 387 Soft Winds Village Dr, Rock Hill, SC 29730-7637 Rock Hill SC 29730 387 Soft Winds Village Dr
Prior addresses: 2 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751-3700 Islip NY 11751 2 Sutton Pl 212 Pinnacle Rd, Apt 201, Rose Hill, VA 24281-8794 Rose Hill VA 24281 212 Pinnacle Rd, Apt 201 150 Long St, Harrogate, TN 37752-7228 Harrogate TN 37752 150 Long St
Relatives: Ann Mcloughlin, Charles Parks, Darren Mckeen, Denise Mccray, Diedra Pinson, Jenise Pugh, John Mcloughlin, Johnnie Johnson
View Report

John Mcloughlin John H Mcloughlin , Age 73

Lives at 10122 Crepe Myrtle Ct, Fort Myers, FL 33913-9195 Fort Myers FL 33913 10122 Crepe Myrtle Ct
Prior addresses: 607 Riverside Dr, Ormond Beach, FL 32176-7713 Ormond Beach FL 32176 607 Riverside Dr 7235 E Hampton Ave, Ste 110, Mesa, AZ 85209 Mesa AZ 85209 7235 E Hampton Ave, Ste 110
Relatives: Donna Mcloughlin, Alyssa Derasmo, Anthony Mcloughlin, Barbara Mcloughlin, Barbarann Mcloughlin, Caitlin Mcloughlin, Camille Mcloughlin, Charlene Napolitan
View Report

James Callaway James Brian Callaway , Age 27

Lives at 251 Hoyt St, Anchorage, AK 99508-2236 Anchorage AK 99508 251 Hoyt St
Prior addresses: 7710 Boundary Ave, Anchorage, AK 99504-1202 Anchorage AK 99504 7710 Boundary Ave 1534 Antietam DR, Apt 503, Columbus, GA 31907-6672 Columbus GA 31907 1534 Antietam DR, Apt 503 2 Sutton PL, Islip, NY 11751-3700 Islip NY 11751 2 Sutton PL
Relatives: Barbara Callaway, Dawn Callaway, James Callaway, Lauren Callaway, Mollie Callaway, Robert Callaway, Carol Ramsey
View Report

Robert Callaway Robert J Callaway , Age 94

Lives at 5461 Windflower Rd, Rockford, IL 61107-2447 Rockford IL 61107 5461 Windflower Rd
Prior addresses: 2 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751-3700 Islip NY 11751 2 Sutton Pl
Relatives: Barbara Callaway, Dawn Callaway, James Callaway, Lauren Callaway, Mollie Callaway, Robert Callaway, Carol Ramsey
View Report

Rita Mcloughlin Rita D Mcloughlin , Age 101

Lives at 2 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751-3700 Islip NY 11751 2 Sutton Pl
Prior addresses: 30 Knell Dr, Massapequa Park, NY 11762-4014 Massapequa Park NY 11762 30 Knell Dr 16 Skunks Hollow RD, Saint James, NY 11780-1325 Saint James NY 11780 16 Skunks Hollow RD 8 Cranberry Dr, Islip, NY 11751-3702 Islip NY 11751 8 Cranberry Dr
Relatives: Brian Foster, Darren Mckeen, John Mcloughlin, Patrick Mcloughlin, Paula Foster, Richard Mcloughlin, Rita Foster, Rita Mcloughlin, Barbarann Mcloughlin
View Report


Neighbors

4 Sutton Pl
Islip, NY
View Property Report
6 Sutton Pl
Islip, NY
View Property Report
8 Sutton Pl
Islip, NY
View Property Report
1 Sutton Pl
Islip, NY
View Property Report

FAQs

Who lives at 2 Sutton Pl, Islip, NY 11751?
According to our records, the current person living in 2 Sutton Pl is Dawn Callaway.
Is this property currently for sale?
The property is not for sale and last sold for $395,000 on Oct 22, 2025. Use USPhoneBook to review nearby listings or compare similar homes in the area.
What is the estimated value of this property?
The estimated value is $800,000, reflecting a 3% change over the past year. You can explore price history and tax records to see how the value has changed over time.
How big is this property?
It features approximately 2,000 sq ft of living space on a 3,485 sq ft lot, built in 1992 and classified as a Single Family.
What nearby properties can I compare this to?
Nearby homes include 4 Sutton Pl, 6 Sutton Pl, and 8 Sutton Pl, each with its own property report to help compare size, value, and residents.