2. 209 E Bailey St Payne OH
209 E Bailey St Payne OH

Report Results for

209 E Bailey St Payne, OH

209 E Bailey St Payne, OH 45880 was built in 1977 and last sold for $99,000. The property has a lot size of 5,837 Sq Ft lot and is listed as a Single Family. The property is currently not for sale. Current estimates place the value near 100,000, reflecting a 25% change over the past year, with 2 beds, 1 baths, and approximately 768 sq ft of living space. If you are looking to buy or rent a property, use USPhoneBook's property database to avoid rental scams, understand tax liabilities, and get a sense of the property's value over time. You can also check out the neighborhood section and see nearby homes, last sold for prices, tax records and more.
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Public Facts

$99,000
Last sold Nov 18, 2025
2
Beds
1
Baths
768
Sqft
Off Market
$100,000 estimated value
Built in 1977
$130/sqft
5,837 lot sqft

Property characteristics

Property type
Residential
Zoning type
Single Family
APN
19-09S-062-00
Parking
1
Subdivision
Gibsons First Addition
Heating
Yes
Cooling
None
Stories
1

Property History

Over the last 12 months, the sales price of 209 E Bailey St Payne, OH 45880 has increased by 25%, and the tax increased by 26%.

Price History

Expand
Collapse
Year Price Price/Sq Ft
2026 $ 99,000 25 % $ 129
2025 $ 79,000 -12 % $ 103
2024 $ 90,000 40 % $ 117
2023 $ 64,000 23 % $ 83
2022 $ 52,000 -13 % $ 68
2021 $ 60,000 ---- $ 78

Tax History

Expand
Collapse
Year Taxes Assesments
2025 $ 939 26 % $ 24,540
2024 $ 743 4 % $ 18,170
2023 $ 715 -1 % $ 18,170
2022 $ 722 8 % $ 18,170
2021 $ 666 ---- $ 14,040
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Owner

Gary Keys Gary William Keys , Age 67

Lives at 134 Olivick Cir NE, Palm Bay, FL 32907-1127
Relatives: Celeste Keys, Amy Keys, Gary Keys, George Keys, Kelly James, Matthew Keys, Melissa Mencarelli, Nickolas Keys, Stephanie Keys
View Report

People Living at 209 E Bailey St Payne, OH

Gary Keys Gary William Keys , Age 67

Lives at 134 Olivick Cir NE, Palm Bay, FL 32907-1127 Palm Bay FL 32907 134 Olivick Cir NE
Prior addresses: 209 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 209 E Bailey St 1250 Helliwell St NW, Palm Bay, FL 32907-7979 Palm Bay FL 32907 1250 Helliwell St NW 1455 Starboard St NW, Palm Bay, FL 32907-7032 Palm Bay FL 32907 1455 Starboard St NW
Relatives: Celeste Keys, Amy Keys, Gary Keys, George Keys, Kelly James, Matthew Keys, Melissa Mencarelli, Nickolas Keys, Stephanie Keys
View Report

Jordan Banks Jordan D Banks , Age 19

Lives at 209 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 209 E Bailey St
Prior addresses: 8517 State Route 49, Payne, OH 45880-9148 Payne OH 45880 8517 State Route 49
Relatives: Jacob Banks, Jason Banks, Melanie Banks, Andrea Banks, Angilean Hall, Cathy Banks, Francis Aldred, Joann Aldred
View Report

Jennifer Sells Jennifer Kay Sells , Age 49

Lives at 215 W Oak St, Payne, OH 45880-9485 Payne OH 45880 215 W Oak St
Prior addresses: 209 E Bailey ST, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 209 E Bailey ST 518 PO Box, Payne, OH 45880-0518 Payne OH 45880 518 PO Box 4776 County Road 34, Waterloo, IN 46793-9728 Waterloo IN 46793 4776 County Road 34
Relatives: Kevin Sells, Alan Diehl, Ashlee Sells, Janel Diehl, Kay Diehl, Maya Sells, Patricia Diehl, Spencer Sells
View Report

Seth May Seth Derik May , Age 34

Lives at 316 W Oak St, Payne, OH 45880-9482 Payne OH 45880 316 W Oak St
Prior addresses: 209 E Bailey ST, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 209 E Bailey ST 431 PO Box, Payne, OH 45880-0431 Payne OH 45880 431 PO Box 7951 State Route 111, Paulding, OH 45879-8751 Paulding OH 45879 7951 State Route 111
Relatives: Carol May, Maria Dirham, Michelle Hire, Rebecca Kraner, Rebecca May, Seth May, Andrew Kraner, Angela Schweizer, Bruce Bosnjak
View Report

Maria Dirham Maria C Dirham , Age 30

Lives at 316 W Oak St, Payne, OH 45880-9482 Payne OH 45880 316 W Oak St
Prior addresses: 209 E Bailey ST, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 209 E Bailey ST 431 PO Box, Payne, OH 45880-0431 Payne OH 45880 431 PO Box 7951 State Route 111, Paulding, OH 45879-8751 Paulding OH 45879 7951 State Route 111
Relatives: Bruce Bosnjak, Camille Dirham, Carol May, Eric Dirham, Janet Bosnjak, Katrina Steen, Maria Sostre, Michelle Hire, Seth May
View Report

Melissa Mencarelli Melissa Mencarelli , Age 40

Lives at 7702 State Route 49, Payne, OH 45880-9413 Payne OH 45880 7702 State Route 49
Prior addresses: 970 Tahiti Ave SE, Palm Bay, FL 32909-5159 Palm Bay FL 32909 970 Tahiti Ave SE 209 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 209 E Bailey St 9702 Mettert Rd, Woodburn, IN 46797-9797 Woodburn IN 46797 9702 Mettert Rd
Relatives: Amy Keys, Carlo Mencarelli, Celeste Keys, Gary Keys, George Keys, Mary Mencarelli, Matthew Keys, Nickolas Keys, Tiffany Keys
View Report

Tiffany Tucker Tiffany Janelle Tucker , Age 30

Lives at 134 Olivick Cir NE, Palm Bay, FL 32907-1127 Palm Bay FL 32907 134 Olivick Cir NE
Prior addresses: 322 Columbus Cir NE, Calhoun, GA 30701-9252 Calhoun GA 30701 322 Columbus Cir NE 209 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 209 E Bailey St
Relatives: Amy Keys, Bradley Tucker, Celeste Keys, Gary Keys, George Keys, Matthew Keys, Melissa Mencarelli, Nickolas Keys, Tiffany Keys
View Report

Shelley Mullins Shelley Kay Mullins , Age 53

Lives at 514 W Merrin St, Payne, OH 45880-9473 Payne OH 45880 514 W Merrin St
Prior addresses: 3306 Mckinnie Ave, Fort Wayne, IN 46806-4535 Fort Wayne IN 46806 3306 Mckinnie Ave 209 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 209 E Bailey St Po Box 677, Payne, OH 45880-0677 Payne OH 45880 Po Box 677
Relatives: Shawn Mullins, Adreana Mullins, Angela Mullins, Celestia Sykes, Danielle Whiting, Deborah Peoples, Erin Scott, James Whiting, Jimmy Scott
View Report

Nickolas Keys Nickolas William Keys , Age 39

Lives at 134 Olivick Cir NE, Palm Bay, FL 32907-1127 Palm Bay FL 32907 134 Olivick Cir NE
Prior addresses: 209 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 209 E Bailey St 9702 Mettert Rd, Woodburn, IN 46797-9797 Woodburn IN 46797 9702 Mettert Rd 7514 Saint Joe Center Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46835-2739 Fort Wayne IN 46835 7514 Saint Joe Center Rd
Relatives: Amy Keys, Celeste Keys, Gary Keys, George Keys, Kelly James, Matthew Keys, Melissa Mencarelli, Stephanie Keys, Stephanie Sinor
View Report


Neighbors

205 E Bailey St
Payne, OH
View Property Report
Bailey St
Payne, OH
View Property Report
Laura St
Payne, OH
View Property Report
219 E Bailey St
Payne, OH
View Property Report

FAQs

Who lives at 209 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880?
According to our records, the current person living in 209 E Bailey St is Gary Keys.
Is this property currently for sale?
The property is not for sale and last sold for $99,000 on Nov 18, 2025. Use USPhoneBook to review nearby listings or compare similar homes in the area.
What is the estimated value of this property?
The estimated value is $100,000, reflecting a 25% change over the past year. You can explore price history and tax records to see how the value has changed over time.
How big is this property?
It features approximately 768 sq ft of living space on a 5,837 sq ft lot, built in 1977 and classified as a Single Family.
What nearby properties can I compare this to?
Nearby homes include 205 E Bailey St, Bailey St, and Laura St, each with its own property report to help compare size, value, and residents.