2. 3735 Eagle Ave Key West FL
3735 Eagle Ave Key West FL

Report Results for

3735 Eagle Ave Key West, FL

3735 Eagle Ave Key West, FL 33040 was built in 1958 and last sold for $1,500,000. The property has a lot size of 6,000 Sq Ft lot and is listed as a Single Family. The property is currently not for sale. Current estimates place the value near 1,396,000, reflecting a -18% change over the past year, with 3 beds, 2 baths, and approximately 1,657 sq ft of living space. If you are looking to buy or rent a property, use USPhoneBook's property database to avoid rental scams, understand tax liabilities, and get a sense of the property's value over time. You can also check out the neighborhood section and see nearby homes, last sold for prices, tax records and more.
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Public Facts

$1,500,000
Last sold Feb 26, 2026
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,657
Sqft
Off Market
$1,396,000 estimated value
Built in 1958
$842/sqft
6,000 lot sqft
$475 HOA fees

Property characteristics

Property type
Residential
Zoning type
Single Family
APN
00053610-000000
Parking
2
Subdivision
Key West Foundation Cos Plat No 1
Heating
Forced air unit
Cooling
Yes
Stories
1

Property History

Over the last 12 months, the sales price of 3735 Eagle Ave Key West, FL 33040 has decreased by -18%.

Price History

Expand
Collapse
Year Price Price/Sq Ft
2026 $ 1,546,000 -18 % $ 933
2025 $ 1,903,000 29 % $ 1,148
2024 $ 1,469,000 5 % $ 887
2023 $ 1,387,000 57 % $ 837
2022 $ 881,000 13 % $ 532
2021 $ 776,000 ---- $ 468

Tax History

Expand
Collapse
Year Taxes Assesments
2025 ---- $ 645,368
2024 $ 5,303 1 %
2023 $ 5,213 4 % $ 608,913
2022 $ 4,987 -2 % $ 591,178
2021 $ 5,098 ---- $ 573,960
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Owner

Geoffrey Herter Geoffrey Elvin Herter , Age 76

Lives at 1625 Patricia St, Key West, FL 33040-5315
Relatives: Lisa Herter, Andrea Schaffner, Brett Herter, Christian Herter, Rebecca Herter, William Herter, Andrea Herter, Avery Awwa, Caroline Jackson
View Report

People Living at 3735 Eagle Ave Key West, FL

Geoffrey Herter Geoffrey Elvin Herter , Age 76

Lives at 1625 Patricia St, Key West, FL 33040-5315 Key West FL 33040 1625 Patricia St
Prior addresses: 3735 Eagle Ave, Key West, FL 33040-4524 Key West FL 33040 3735 Eagle Ave 84 Mares Hill Rd, Ivoryton, CT 06442-1257 Ivoryton CT 06442 84 Mares Hill Rd
Relatives: Lisa Herter, Andrea Schaffner, Brett Herter, Christian Herter, Rebecca Herter, William Herter, Andrea Herter, Avery Awwa, Caroline Jackson
View Report

Kim Sprague Kim Carney Sprague , Age 69

Lives at 107 Wood Ibis Ct, Daytona Beach, FL 32119-1372 Daytona Beach FL 32119 107 Wood Ibis Ct
Prior addresses: 2130 Herring XING, Murfreesboro, TN 37130-3489 Murfreesboro TN 37130 2130 Herring XING
Relatives: Billy Sprague, Alice Carney, Cody Sprague, Jack Pevovaroff, Kevin Pevovaroff, Margaret Pevovaroff, Thomas Carney
View Report

Karl Gouzd Karl Aron Gouzd , Age 62

Lives at 53 Boundary Ln, Key West, FL 33040-6302 Key West FL 33040 53 Boundary Ln
Prior addresses: 91 PO Box, Rachel, WV 26587-0091 Rachel WV 26587 91 PO Box
Relatives: Clara Gouzd, Karl Gouzd, Lucy Gomillion, Caton Gomillion, Helen Gouzd, Krystal Gomillion, Krystal Schadle, Louise Gouzd
View Report

Cody Sprague Cody Wayne Sprague , Age 46

Lives at 8654 NE 91st Ter, Kansas City, MO 64157-6214 Kansas City MO 64157 8654 NE 91st Ter
Prior addresses: 3721 W Capital Ave, Apt A206, Grand Island, NE 68803-1207 Grand Island NE 68803 3721 W Capital Ave, Apt A206 2711 Idaho Ave, Grand Island, NE 68803-1152 Grand Island NE 68803 2711 Idaho Ave
Relatives: Billy Sprague, Jennifer Sprague, Kim Sprague, Megan Sprague, Alice Carney, Angela Rodriguez, Jack Pevovaroff, Kevin Pevovaroff
View Report

Billy Sprague Billy Wayne Sprague , Age 69

Lives at 1202 Heartland Rd, Rm R215, Saint Joseph, MO 64506-3243 Saint Joseph MO 64506 1202 Heartland Rd, Rm R215
Prior addresses: 2130 Herring XING, Murfreesboro, TN 37130-3489 Murfreesboro TN 37130 2130 Herring XING
Relatives: Kim Sprague, Angela Rodriguez, Cody Sprague, Jennifer Sprague, Rena Hawkins, Roma Sprague, William Sprague, Abigail Rodriguez, Alice Carney
View Report

Wayne Fey Wayne David Fey , Age 72

Lives at 1370 Falling Spring Rd, Glasgow, VA 24555-2181 Glasgow VA 24555 1370 Falling Spring Rd
Prior addresses: 145 Gingerbread Ln, Glasgow, VA 24555-3023 Glasgow VA 24555 145 Gingerbread Ln Po Box 1541, Ellicott City, MD 21041-1541 Ellicott City MD 21041 Po Box 1541 3115 Laurel Hill Rd, Hanover, MD 21076-2327 Hanover MD 21076 3115 Laurel Hill Rd
Relatives: Laura Fey, Robin Price, Wayne Fey, Anna Lemoine, Doris Hineman, Kenneth Lemoine, Madison Price, Max Hineman
View Report

Helen Fitzgerald Helen Mary Fitzgerald , Age 90

Lives at 50 Washington St, Unit 1, Charlestown, MA 02129-3209 Charlestown MA 02129 50 Washington St, Unit 1
Prior addresses: 292 Waltham St, Lexington, MA 02421-6915 Lexington MA 02421 292 Waltham St
Relatives: William Fitzgerald, Garrett Fitzgerald, James Fitzgerald, John Fitzgerald, Lisa Fitzgerald, Michelle Fitzgerald, Barbara Fitzgerald
View Report

David Willett David Gary Willett , Age 69

Lives at 705 Foreman Dr, Lafayette, LA 70506-5333 Lafayette LA 70506 705 Foreman Dr
Prior addresses: 625 N Plymouth Blvd, Los Angeles, CA 90004-1471 Los Angeles CA 90004 625 N Plymouth Blvd 120 Banks Ave, Lafayette, LA 70506-1917 Lafayette LA 70506 120 Banks Ave
Relatives: Dacia Cabo, Amanda Willett, Ava Willett, Carolle Willett, Cheryllene Willett, Cole Willett, David Willett, Dellman Willett
View Report

John Buckner John William Buckner , Age 88

Lives at 1123 SE 5th Ave, Arcadia, FL 34266-7417 Arcadia FL 34266 1123 SE 5th Ave
Prior addresses: 517 Belvedere Ct, Punta Gorda, FL 33950-6426 Punta Gorda FL 33950 517 Belvedere Ct 2241 W Benjamin Holt Dr, Stockton, CA 95207-3349 Stockton CA 95207 2241 W Benjamin Holt Dr 2627 PO Box, Arcadia, FL 34265-2627 Arcadia FL 34265 2627 PO Box
Relatives: Amanda Sandoval, Maria T, Abel J, Benjamin Sandoval, Carlota Sandoval, Elizabeth Buckner, Fidel Salazar, Frank Salazar, Kathleen Salazar
View Report


Neighbors

3741 Eagle Ave
Key West, FL
View Property Report
3801 Eagle Ave
Key West, FL
View Property Report
1400 20th St
Key West, FL
View Property Report
3731 Eagle Ave
Key West, FL
View Property Report

FAQs

Who lives at 3735 Eagle Ave, Key West, FL 33040?
According to our records, the current person living in 3735 Eagle Ave is Geoffrey Herter.
Is this property currently for sale?
The property is not for sale and last sold for $1,500,000 on Feb 26, 2026. Use USPhoneBook to review nearby listings or compare similar homes in the area.
What is the estimated value of this property?
The estimated value is $1,396,000, reflecting a -18% change over the past year. You can explore price history and tax records to see how the value has changed over time.
How big is this property?
It features approximately 1,657 sq ft of living space on a 6,000 sq ft lot, built in 1958 and classified as a Single Family.
What nearby properties can I compare this to?
Nearby homes include 3741 Eagle Ave, 3801 Eagle Ave, and 1400 20th St, each with its own property report to help compare size, value, and residents.