2. 3964 Florida Ave Jay FL
3964 Florida Ave Jay FL

Report Results for

3964 Florida Ave Jay, FL

3964 Florida Ave Jay, FL 32565 was built in 2011 and last sold for $4,360,000. The property has a lot size of 295,511 Sq Ft lot and is listed as a Convalescent/Nursing Home. The property is currently not for sale. If you are looking to buy or rent a property, use USPhoneBook's property database to avoid rental scams, understand tax liabilities, and get a sense of the property's value over time. You can also check out the neighborhood section and see nearby homes, last sold for prices, tax records and more.
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Public Facts

$4,360,000
Last sold Dec 18, 2025
57
Beds
61
Baths
32,534
Sqft
Off Market
Built in 2011
295,511 lot sqft

Property characteristics

Property type
Exempt
Zoning type
Convalescent/Nursing Home
APN
41-5N-29-0000-01808-0000
Heating
Forced air unit
Cooling
Central
Fireplaces
1
Stories
1

Property History

Over the last 12 months, the tax of 3964 Florida Ave Jay, FL 32565 has increased by 9%.
There is currently no price history available.

Tax History

Expand
Collapse
Year Taxes Assesments
2025 $ 40,303 9 % $ 2,329,152
2024 $ 36,891 -2 % $ 2,347,447
2023 $ 37,670 0 % $ 2,369,154
2022 $ 37,634 -3 % $ 2,348,949
2021 $ 39,080 ---- $ 2,386,652
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Owner

Jimmy Carnley Jimmy Crawford Carnley , Age 79

Lives at 3964 Florida Ave, RM 327, Jay, FL 32565-1104
Relatives: Karen Carnley, Bryce Carnley, James Carnley, Jimmy Carnely, Katherine Martha, Sara Carnley, Alianne Lewis, Allen Carnley
View Report

People Living at 3964 Florida Ave Jay, FL

Jimmy Carnley Jimmy Crawford Carnley , Age 79

Lives at 3964 Florida Ave, RM 327, Jay, FL 32565-1104 Jay FL 32565 3964 Florida Ave, RM 327
Prior addresses: 4280 Willow St, Milton, FL 32571-2241 Milton FL 32571 4280 Willow St 5122 Dickens Ct, Milton, FL 32571-6227 Milton FL 32571 5122 Dickens Ct
Relatives: Karen Carnley, Bryce Carnley, James Carnley, Jimmy Carnely, Katherine Martha, Sara Carnley, Alianne Lewis, Allen Carnley
View Report

Darlene Monroe Darlene Delann Monroe , Age 88

Lives at 3964 Florida Ave, Jay, FL 32565-1104 Jay FL 32565 3964 Florida Ave
Prior addresses: 8436 Chumuckla Hwy, Pace, FL 32571-9236 Pace FL 32571 8436 Chumuckla Hwy 8436 Chumuckla Hwy, Milton, FL 32571-9236 Milton FL 32571 8436 Chumuckla Hwy 43 W Campus View Blvd, Columbus, OH 43235-1450 Columbus OH 43235 43 W Campus View Blvd
Relatives: Jack Price, Kimberly Conrad, Raiza Costa, Robert Monroe, Adrian Conrad, Arlo Living, Dorothy Moody, Howl Moody
View Report

Wilma Lutz Wilma Sue Lutz , Age 80

Lives at 4065A Highway 4, Jay, FL 32565-9796 Jay FL 32565 4065A Highway 4
Prior addresses: 3964 Florida Ave, Jay, FL 32565-1104 Jay FL 32565 3964 Florida Ave 5274 Cherry St, Jay, FL 32565-3111 Jay FL 32565 5274 Cherry St Po Box 23, Jay, FL 32565-0023 Jay FL 32565 Po Box 23
Relatives: Carol Martinez, Chelsea Lutz, Chris Lutz, George Lutz, James Lutz, John Lutz, Susan Lutz
View Report

Patricia Thompson Patricia L Thompson , Age 71

Lives at 5195 Blackmon Dr, Jay, FL 32565-1190 Jay FL 32565 5195 Blackmon Dr
Prior addresses: 3964 Florida Ave, Jay, FL 32565-1104 Jay FL 32565 3964 Florida Ave 5103 NW 24th Ave, Miami, FL 33142-3623 Miami FL 33142 5103 NW 24th Ave
Relatives: Craig Thomas, Dan Thomas, Emma Thomas, Jeffery Alexander, Larry Thompson, Lisa Thomas, Patricia Thomas
View Report

Terry Barton Terry D Barton , Age 81

Lives at 3964 Florida Ave, Jay, FL 32565-1104 Jay FL 32565 3964 Florida Ave
Prior addresses: 3460 Pine Tree Ct, Milton, FL 32571-8926 Milton FL 32571 3460 Pine Tree Ct 1604 Eunice Ln, Baker, FL 32531-8493 Baker FL 32531 1604 Eunice Ln 3460 Pine Tree Ct, Pace, FL 32571-8926 Pace FL 32571 3460 Pine Tree Ct
Relatives: Andrea Barton, Buren Barton, Jackson Beth, Johnny Barrow, Karen Athey, Karen Howard, Kenneth Barrow, Leah Mcmillan
View Report

Bea Polk Bea Polk , Age 103

Lives at 9000 N Palafox St, Lot B, Pensacola, FL 32534-3062 Pensacola FL 32534 9000 N Palafox St, Lot B
Prior addresses: 3964 Florida Ave, Jay, FL 32565-1104 Jay FL 32565 3964 Florida Ave Po Box 2, Cantonment, FL 32533-0002 Cantonment FL 32533 Po Box 2 1100 Pauline ST, Cantonment, FL 32533-9040 Cantonment FL 32533 1100 Pauline ST
Relatives: Addie Gomillion, Collis Enterkin, Glenda Thompson, Amanda Bledsoe, Christopher Thompson, Clyde Thompson, Daniel Thompson, Debra Polk
View Report

Sylvia Whitfield Sylvia G Whitfield , Age 92

Lives at 3964 Florida Ave, Jay, FL 32565-1104 Jay FL 32565 3964 Florida Ave
Prior addresses: 5837 N Airport Rd, Milton, FL 32583-8691 Milton FL 32583 5837 N Airport Rd 988 Porter RD, Decatur, GA 30032-1755 Decatur GA 30032 988 Porter RD 1114 Willivee Dr, Decatur, GA 30033-4112 Decatur GA 30033 1114 Willivee Dr
Relatives: Edgar Whitfield, Cleveland Whitfield, Kristen Whitfield, Alice Barnes, Amy Mcdowell, Amy Templet, Andrew Whitfield, Annette Craft
View Report

Elizabeth Malshuk Elizabeth Ann Malshuk , Age 79

Lives at 3964 Florida Ave, Jay, FL 32565-1104 Jay FL 32565 3964 Florida Ave
Prior addresses: 5116 Hendricks Cir, Jay, FL 32565-3121 Jay FL 32565 5116 Hendricks Cir 4491 Custer Ln, Jay, FL 32565-2831 Jay FL 32565 4491 Custer Ln
Relatives: Nicholiaes Malshuk, Susan Malshuk, Belinda Hawthorne, Brittany Hawthorne, Calvin Hawthorne, Carla Hawthorne, Cheryl Wassmer, Courtney Moody
View Report

Richard Norris Richard Edward Norris , Age 74

Lives at 3964 Florida Ave, Jay, FL 32565-1104 Jay FL 32565 3964 Florida Ave
Prior addresses: 5213 Admiral Halsey Rd, Milton, FL 32583-5440 Milton FL 32583 5213 Admiral Halsey Rd Po Box 26, Milton, FL 32572-0026 Milton FL 32572 Po Box 26 831 Esconditas Pl, Pensacola, FL 32506-3716 Pensacola FL 32506 831 Esconditas Pl
Relatives: Claudine Norris, Jason Norris, Kelly Norris, Anthony Mascorro, Blake Mcdonald, Darien Mascorro, Emilee Norris, Ernest Mcdonald
View Report


Neighbors

, FL
View Property Report
3995 Florida Ave
Jay, FL
View Property Report
, FL
View Property Report
Florida Ave
Jay, FL
View Property Report

FAQs

Who lives at 3964 Florida Ave, Jay, FL 32565?
According to our records, the current person living in 3964 Florida Ave is Jimmy Carnley.
Is this property currently for sale?
The property is not for sale and last sold for $4,360,000 on Dec 18, 2025. Use USPhoneBook to review nearby listings or compare similar homes in the area.
What is the estimated value of this property?
We currently do not have sufficient data to provide an estimated value or recent price trends for this property. You may still explore nearby properties or historical records for additional insights.
How big is this property?
It features approximately 32,534 sq ft of living space on a 295,511 sq ft lot, built in 2011 and classified as a Convalescent/Nursing Home.
What nearby properties can I compare this to?
Nearby homes include , 3995 Florida Ave, and , each with its own property report to help compare size, value, and residents.