2. 509 E 3rd St Prophetstown IL
509 E 3rd St Prophetstown IL

Report Results for

509 E 3rd St Prophetstown, IL

509 E 3rd St Prophetstown, IL 61277 The property has a lot size of 7,500 Sq Ft lot and is listed as a Single Family. The property is currently not for sale. Current estimates place the value near 110,000, reflecting a -12% change over the past year, with available bedroom details. If you are looking to buy or rent a property, use USPhoneBook's property database to avoid rental scams, understand tax liabilities, and get a sense of the property's value over time. You can also check out the neighborhood section and see nearby homes, last sold for prices, tax records and more.
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Public Facts

 
Last sold Sep 16, 2025
Off Market
$110,000 estimated value
7,500 lot sqft

Property characteristics

Property type
Residential
Zoning type
Single Family
APN
2104203004
Subdivision
Plautz Subdivision

Property History

Over the last 12 months, the sales price of 509 E 3rd St Prophetstown, IL 61277 has decreased by -12%, and the tax increased by 14%.

Price History

Expand
Collapse
Year Price Price/Sq Ft
2026 $ 137,000 -12 %
2025 $ 156,000 87 %
2024 $ 83,000 36 %
2023 $ 61,000 3 %
2022 $ 59,000 15 %
2021 $ 51,000 ----

Tax History

Expand
Collapse
Year Taxes Assesments
2025 $ 1,570 14 % $ 24,948
2024 $ 1,370 14 % $ 22,089
2023 $ 1,193 17 % $ 20,141
2022 $ 1,016 11 % $ 17,738
2021 $ 908 ---- $ 16,149
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Owner

Matthew Reutzel Matthew S Reutzel , Age 49

Lives at 1625 Riverside Cir, Dixon, IL 61021-2645
Relatives: Shana Reutzel, Andrew Reutzel, Carolyn Reutzel, Connie Reutzel, Donald Reutzel, Laura Leipart, Michele Williams, Michelle Williams, Steven Reutzel
View Report

People Living at 509 E 3rd St Prophetstown, IL

Matthew Reutzel Matthew S Reutzel , Age 49

Lives at 1625 Riverside Cir, Dixon, IL 61021-2645 Dixon IL 61021 1625 Riverside Cir
Prior addresses: 509 E 3rd St, Prophetstown, IL 61277-1306 Prophetstown IL 61277 509 E 3rd St 113 Sunset Ln, Bolingbrook, IL 60440-2330 Bolingbrook IL 60440 113 Sunset Ln
Relatives: Shana Reutzel, Andrew Reutzel, Carolyn Reutzel, Connie Reutzel, Donald Reutzel, Laura Leipart, Michele Williams, Michelle Williams, Steven Reutzel
View Report

Andrew Reutzel Andrew Stewart Reutzel , Age 27

Lives at 509 E 3rd St, Prophetstown, IL 61277-1306 Prophetstown IL 61277 509 E 3rd St
Prior addresses: 510 1st St E, Lyndon, IL 61261-9701 Lyndon IL 61261 510 1st St E
Relatives: Matthew Reutzel, Shana Reutzel, Sydnie Reutzel, Carolyn Reutzel, Connie Reutzel, Donald Reutzel, Jesse Shere, Laura Leipart, Michele Williams
View Report

Thomas Shere Thomas Leroy Shere , Age 70

Lives at 13775 Howard Rd, Prophetstown, IL 61277-9704 Prophetstown IL 61277 13775 Howard Rd
Prior addresses: 509 E 3rd St, Prophetstown, IL 61277-1306 Prophetstown IL 61277 509 E 3rd St 14370 Springhill Rd, Prophetstown, IL 61277-9710 Prophetstown IL 61277 14370 Springhill Rd 219 Washington St, Apt B, Prophetstown, IL 61277-1179 Prophetstown IL 61277 219 Washington St, Apt B
Relatives: Teresa Tank, Jesse Shere, Shana Reutzel, Andrew Reutzel, Matthew Reutzel, Sydnie Reutzel, Alonzo Williams, Becky Williams, Carolyn Reutzel
View Report

Shana Reutzel Shana S Reutzel , Age 47

Lives at 509 E 3rd St, Prophetstown, IL 61277-1306 Prophetstown IL 61277 509 E 3rd St
Prior addresses: Po Box 76, Tampico, IL 61283-0076 Tampico IL 61283 Po Box 76 13775 Howard Rd, Prophetstown, IL 61277-9704 Prophetstown IL 61277 13775 Howard Rd
Relatives: Matthew Reutzel, Andrew Reutzel, Jesse Shere, Sydnie Reutzel, Teresa Tank, Thomas Shere, Carolyn Reutzel, Connie Reutzel, Donald Reutzel
View Report

Sydnie Reutzel Sydnie S Reutzel , Age 26

Lives at 2252 S Franzy DR, Decatur, IL 62521-5577 Decatur IL 62521 2252 S Franzy DR
Prior addresses: 509 E 3rd St, Prophetstown, IL 61277-1306 Prophetstown IL 61277 509 E 3rd St
Relatives: Andrew Reutzel, Matthew Reutzel, Shana Reutzel, Carolyn Reutzel, Connie Reutzel, Donald Reutzel, Jesse Shere, Laura Leipart, Michele Williams
View Report

Michelle Castle Michelle Lee Castle , Age 54

Lives at 1842 Whitney Rd, Sherman, TX 75090-3295 Sherman TX 75090 1842 Whitney Rd
Prior addresses: 104 N Wood Ave, Denison, TX 75020-3553 Denison TX 75020 104 N Wood Ave 138 N Imperial Dr, Denison, TX 75020-3571 Denison TX 75020 138 N Imperial Dr 409 E 3rd St, Prophetstown, IL 61277-1305 Prophetstown IL 61277 409 E 3rd St
Relatives: Dan Castle, Anthony Castle, Brenda Trainor, Brittany Horton, Carolyn Daniels, Charles Horton, Christopher Castle, Janet Horton
View Report

Gail Robnett Gail L Robnett , Age 56

Lives at 1002 W 8th St, Sterling, IL 61081-3241 Sterling IL 61081 1002 W 8th St
Prior addresses: 1008 10th Ave, Rock Falls, IL 61071-2756 Rock Falls IL 61071 1008 10th Ave 1905 Mcneil Rd, Rock Falls, IL 61071-3223 Rock Falls IL 61071 1905 Mcneil Rd 2801 Mcneil Rd, Rock Falls, IL 61071-3509 Rock Falls IL 61071 2801 Mcneil Rd
Relatives: Amy Cervantes, April Robnett, Becky Smith, Dawn Sherman, Dawn Smith, Doris Smith, Jacob Robnett, James Smith, Jesse Smith
View Report

Dan Castle Dan D Castle , Age 68

Lives at 1842 Whitney Rd, Sherman, TX 75090-3295 Sherman TX 75090 1842 Whitney Rd
Prior addresses: 104 N Wood Ave, Denison, TX 75020-3553 Denison TX 75020 104 N Wood Ave 138 N Imperial Dr, Denison, TX 75020-3571 Denison TX 75020 138 N Imperial Dr 410 E Day St, Denison, TX 75021-4812 Denison TX 75021 410 E Day St
Relatives: Michelle Castle, Anthony Castle, Christopher Castle, Kira Castle, Brenda Trainor, Brittany Horton, Carolyn Daniels, Charles Horton
View Report

Ashley Tiemann Ashley Edward Tiemann , Age 58

Lives at 4085 Kendall Dr, Saint Joseph, MI 49085-9559 Saint Joseph MI 49085 4085 Kendall Dr
Prior addresses: 120 Lakeview Dr, Hamilton, GA 31811-4365 Hamilton GA 31811 120 Lakeview Dr 1317 Prophetstown Rd, Rock Falls, IL 61071-1065 Rock Falls IL 61071 1317 Prophetstown Rd 6798 Yorktown Rd, Prophetstown, IL 61277-9133 Prophetstown IL 61277 6798 Yorktown Rd
Relatives: Adam Tiemann, Anthony Tiemann, Antoinette Ford, Ashley Tiemann, Brandy Darby, Chase Tiemann, Clara Tiemann, Erika Francis, George Tiemann
View Report

James Smith James Dean Smith , Age 58

Lives at 1905 E Powell Ave, Evansville, IN 47714-2141 Evansville IN 47714 1905 E Powell Ave
Prior addresses: Po Box 21, Tampico, IL 61283-0021 Tampico IL 61283 Po Box 21 306 N Joy St, UNIT 21, Tampico, IL 61283-7724 Tampico IL 61283 306 N Joy St, UNIT 21 1138 Backbone Rd, Tampico, IL 61283-9009 Tampico IL 61283 1138 Backbone Rd
Relatives: Joanne Smith, Carol Smith, Gail Robnett, Reva Isaacs, Rhonda J, Rickisha Hathaway, Ronald Smith, Amanda Smith, Amy Cervantes
View Report


Neighbors

511 E 3rd St
Prophetstown, IL
View Property Report
507 E 3rd St
Prophetstown, IL
View Property Report
305 Maple St
Prophetstown, IL
View Property Report
309 Maple St
Prophetstown, IL
View Property Report

FAQs

Who lives at 509 E 3rd St, Prophetstown, IL 61277?
According to our records, the current person living in 509 E 3rd St is Matthew Reutzel.
Is this property currently for sale?
The property is not for sale. Use USPhoneBook to review nearby listings or compare similar homes in the area.
What is the estimated value of this property?
The estimated value is $110,000, reflecting a -12% change over the past year. You can explore price history and tax records to see how the value has changed over time.
How big is this property?
Complete property size and structural details are currently unavailable.
What nearby properties can I compare this to?
Nearby homes include 511 E 3rd St, 507 E 3rd St, and 305 Maple St, each with its own property report to help compare size, value, and residents.