2. 537 E Wheeling St Lancaster OH
537 E Wheeling St Lancaster OH

Report Results for

537 E Wheeling St Lancaster, OH

537 E Wheeling St Lancaster, OH 43130 was built in 1900 and last sold for $255,000. The property has a lot size of 7,697 Sq Ft lot and is listed as a Single Family. The property is currently not for sale. Current estimates place the value near 261,000, reflecting a 7% change over the past year, with 3 beds, 2 baths, and approximately 1,699 sq ft of living space. If you are looking to buy or rent a property, use USPhoneBook's property database to avoid rental scams, understand tax liabilities, and get a sense of the property's value over time. You can also check out the neighborhood section and see nearby homes, last sold for prices, tax records and more.
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Public Facts

$255,000
Last sold Jun 5, 2026
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,699
Sqft
Off Market
$261,000 estimated value
Built in 1900
$154/sqft
7,697 lot sqft

Property characteristics

Property type
Residential
Zoning type
Single Family
APN
05-33090-300
Subdivision
Works Add
Heating
Central
Cooling
Central
Fireplaces
1
Stories
2

Property History

Over the last 12 months, the sales price of 537 E Wheeling St Lancaster, OH 43130 has increased by 7%, and the tax increased by 43%.

Price History

Expand
Collapse
Year Price Price/Sq Ft
2026 $ 258,000 7 % $ 152
2025 $ 240,000 -4 % $ 141
2024 $ 250,000 7 % $ 147
2023 $ 232,000 31 % $ 137
2022 $ 177,000 4 % $ 104
2021 $ 169,000 ---- $ 99

Tax History

Expand
Collapse
Year Taxes Assesments
2025 $ 6,977 43 % $ 77,610
2024 $ 4,865 147 %
2023 $ 1,968 0 % $ 54,120
2022 $ 1,976 16 % $ 54,120
2021 $ 1,700 ---- $ 43,490
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Owner

Sara Stover Sara Jane Stover , Age 30

Lives at 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823
Relatives: Cameron J, Cathie Effinger, Gerald Effinger, Walter Effinger, Brett Stover, Cassie Gabriel, Diana Effinger, Heather Martin, Hesper Stover
View Report

People Living at 537 E Wheeling St Lancaster, OH

Sara Stover Sara Jane Stover , Age 30

Lives at 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling St
Prior addresses: 328 Reber AVE, Lancaster, OH 43130-1760 Lancaster OH 43130 328 Reber AVE 61 E 1st St, The Plains, OH 45780-1213 The Plains OH 45780 61 E 1st St 2382 E Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130-9307 Lancaster OH 43130 2382 E Main St
Relatives: Cameron J, Cathie Effinger, Gerald Effinger, Walter Effinger, Brett Stover, Cassie Gabriel, Diana Effinger, Heather Martin, Hesper Stover
View Report

Sydney Belville Sydney J Belville , Age 22

Lives at 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling St
Prior addresses: 3255 County Line Rd NE, Rushville, OH 43150-9686 Rushville OH 43150 3255 County Line Rd NE 3055 County Line Rd NE, Rushville, OH 43150-9633 Rushville OH 43150 3055 County Line Rd NE
Relatives: Jon Belville, Natalie Belville, Bernard Belville, Brenda Curry, Christopher Belville, Ginny Overbeck, Joseph Belville, Nathaniel Hughes, Patrick Hughes
View Report

Cameron Stover Cameron G Stover , Age 31

Lives at 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling St
Prior addresses: 328 Reber Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130-1760 Lancaster OH 43130 328 Reber Ave 61 E 1st St, Apt C, The Plains, OH 45780-1290 The Plains OH 45780 61 E 1st St, Apt C 300 W State St, Apt I8, Athens, OH 45701-1554 Athens OH 45701 300 W State St, Apt I8
Relatives: Brett Stover, Hesper Stover, Paige Stover, Sara Stover, Amanda Stover, Cathie Effinger, Charity Ritchey, Constance Kriese, Diana Stover
View Report

Jeremy Ruff Jeremy Michael Ruff , Age 39

Lives at 1913 Sheridan Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130-1233 Lancaster OH 43130 1913 Sheridan Dr
Prior addresses: 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling St 3800 Old Millersport Rd NE, Lancaster, OH 43130-9727 Lancaster OH 43130 3800 Old Millersport Rd NE 613 Herman AVE, Lemoyne, PA 17043-1824 Lemoyne PA 17043 613 Herman AVE
Relatives: Brad Ruff, Bret Ruff, Kay Ruff, Micole Ruff, Mona Ruff, Neal Ruff, Stephanie Mahon, Amber Mahon, Belinda Mahon
View Report

Micole Ruff Micole Leigh Ruff , Age 39

Lives at 1913 Sheridan Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130-1233 Lancaster OH 43130 1913 Sheridan Dr
Prior addresses: 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling St 118 S Mount Pleasant Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130-3909 Lancaster OH 43130 118 S Mount Pleasant Ave 1258 PO Box, Lancaster, OH 43130-6058 Lancaster OH 43130 1258 PO Box
Relatives: Brad Ruff, Bret Ruff, Bryan Kraft, Charles Kraft, Cynda Kraft, David Kraft, Donald Ruff, Edith Williams
View Report

William Bender William Scott Bender , Age 76

Lives at 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling St
Prior addresses: 824 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3252 Lancaster OH 43130 824 E Wheeling St 2399 Prospect Hill CT, Lancaster, OH 43130-8469 Lancaster OH 43130 2399 Prospect Hill CT 614 1/2 E Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3903 Lancaster OH 43130 614 1/2 E Main St
Relatives: Nina Bender, Erica Daubenmire, Lindsay Browning, William Bender, Barbara Baker, Cierra Riley, Dusty Miller, Erin Browning, Harry Gibson
View Report

Bill Bender Bill Bender

Lives at 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling St
Prior addresses: 936 Goodwin Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130-2169 Lancaster OH 43130 936 Goodwin Ave 309 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3818 Lancaster OH 43130 309 E Wheeling St
View Report

Kegan Mowery Kegan Michael Mowery , Age 20

Lives at 146 N Ewing St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3375 Lancaster OH 43130 146 N Ewing St
Prior addresses: 537 E Wheeling ST, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling ST
View Report

Brandon Kilbarger Brandon Lee Kilbarger , Age 40

Lives at 146 N Ewing St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3375 Lancaster OH 43130 146 N Ewing St
Prior addresses: 3236 Stone Valley RD W, Alamo, CA 94507-1555 Alamo CA 94507 3236 Stone Valley RD W 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling St 535 W Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3672 Lancaster OH 43130 535 W Main St
Relatives: Ashley Barton, Brandon Kilbarger, Jennifer Underwood, Lisa Kilbarger, Terry Kilbarger, Thea Sells, Adrian Sells, Amy Underwood, Brandon Pulsinelli
View Report

Jennifer Underwood Jennifer L Underwood , Age 40

Lives at 146 N Ewing St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3375 Lancaster OH 43130 146 N Ewing St
Prior addresses: 3236 Stone Valley RD W, Alamo, CA 94507-1555 Alamo CA 94507 3236 Stone Valley RD W 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3823 Lancaster OH 43130 537 E Wheeling St 223 N Cherry St, Lancaster, OH 43130-3266 Lancaster OH 43130 223 N Cherry St
Relatives: Amy Underwood, Brandon Kilbarger, Christine Underwood, Christine Wright, Jennifer Young, Nicole Davis, Randy Underwood, Adriana Rosser
View Report


Neighbors

539 E Wheeling St
Lancaster, OH
View Property Report
533 E Wheeling St
Lancaster, OH
View Property Report
543 E Wheeling St
Lancaster, OH
View Property Report
529 E Wheeling St
Lancaster, OH
View Property Report

FAQs

Who lives at 537 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130?
According to our records, the current person living in 537 E Wheeling St is Sara Stover.
Is this property currently for sale?
The property is not for sale and last sold for $255,000 on Jun 5, 2026. Use USPhoneBook to review nearby listings or compare similar homes in the area.
What is the estimated value of this property?
The estimated value is $261,000, reflecting a 7% change over the past year. You can explore price history and tax records to see how the value has changed over time.
How big is this property?
It features approximately 1,699 sq ft of living space on a 7,697 sq ft lot, built in 1900 and classified as a Single Family.
What nearby properties can I compare this to?
Nearby homes include 539 E Wheeling St, 533 E Wheeling St, and 543 E Wheeling St, each with its own property report to help compare size, value, and residents.