2. 205 E Bailey St E Payne OH
205 E Bailey St E Payne OH

Report Results for

205 E Bailey St Payne, OH

205 E Bailey St Payne, OH 45880 was built in 1967 and last sold for $35,725. The property has a lot size of 5,837 Sq Ft lot and is listed as a Single Family. The property is currently not for sale. Current estimates place the value near 168,000, reflecting a 10% change over the past year, with 3 beds, 2 baths, and approximately 1,590 sq ft of living space. If you are looking to buy or rent a property, use USPhoneBook's property database to avoid rental scams, understand tax liabilities, and get a sense of the property's value over time. You can also check out the neighborhood section and see nearby homes, last sold for prices, tax records and more.
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Public Facts

$35,725
Last sold Apr 11, 2025
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,590
Sqft
Off Market
$168,000 estimated value
Built in 1967
$106/sqft
5,837 lot sqft

Property characteristics

Property type
Residential
Zoning type
Single Family
APN
19-09S-063-00
Parking
2
Subdivision
Gibsons First Addition
Heating
Yes
Cooling
Central
Stories
1

Property History

Over the last 12 months, the sales price of 205 E Bailey St Payne, OH 45880 has increased by 10%, and the tax increased by 36%.

Price History

Expand
Collapse
Year Price Price/Sq Ft
2026 $ 155,000 10 % $ 97
2025 $ 140,000 -6 % $ 88
2024 $ 149,000 83 % $ 94
2023 $ 81,000 -14 % $ 51
2022 $ 95,000 5 % $ 60
2021 $ 90,000 ---- $ 57

Tax History

Expand
Collapse
Year Taxes Assesments
2025 $ 1,742 36 % $ 46,520
2024 $ 1,272 4 % $ 31,750
2023 $ 1,223 0 % $ 31,750
2022 $ 1,235 77 % $ 31,750
2021 $ 694 ---- $ 24,220
PropertyReach Sponsored Advertise with Us

Full Property Report

Property Values · Deed History · Ownership History · Foreclosures · Mortgage History

Get More Property Details

Owner

Stacey Carroll Stacey L Carroll , Age 38

Lives at 205 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061
Relatives: Haley Dawson, Paula Dawson, Rodney Dawson, Roxie Carroll, Shane Carroll, Stephanie Hammond, Suzanne Torrey, Allison Germann, Barry Carroll
View Report

People Living at 205 E Bailey St Payne, OH

Stacey Carroll Stacey L Carroll , Age 38

Lives at 205 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey St
Prior addresses: 124 Boyd Ave, Van Wert, OH 45891-2310 Van Wert OH 45891 124 Boyd Ave 303 N Main ST, Convoy, OH 45832-7781 Convoy OH 45832 303 N Main ST 135 Sycamore St, Convoy, OH 45832-7761 Convoy OH 45832 135 Sycamore St
Relatives: Haley Dawson, Paula Dawson, Rodney Dawson, Roxie Carroll, Shane Carroll, Stephanie Hammond, Suzanne Torrey, Allison Germann, Barry Carroll
View Report

Alexa Hornish Alexa Marie Hornish , Age 22

Lives at 23373 Road 140, Oakwood, OH 45873-9307 Oakwood OH 45873 23373 Road 140
Prior addresses: 205 E Bailey ST, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey ST 116 S Maple ST, Payne, OH 45880-9499 Payne OH 45880 116 S Maple ST 2945 Road 177, Grover Hill, OH 45849-9642 Grover Hill OH 45849 2945 Road 177
Relatives: Abby Hornish, Bradley Hornish, Brenda Hornish, Brendan Hornish, Daniel Hornish, Dorothy Hornish, Jarrett Hornish, Jessica Edwards, Kacy Hornish
View Report

Shane Carroll Shane A Carroll , Age 35

Lives at 711 E Main ST, Van Wert, OH 45891-1852 Van Wert OH 45891 711 E Main ST
Prior addresses: 124 Boyd Ave, Van Wert, OH 45891-2310 Van Wert OH 45891 124 Boyd Ave 205 E Bailey ST, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey ST Po Box 495, Convoy, OH 45832-0495 Convoy OH 45832 Po Box 495
Relatives: Barry Carroll, Joshua Carroll, Lisa Carroll, Roxie Carroll, Stacey Carroll, Beth Thomas, Billy Carroll, Brenda Schmidt, Dana Darst
View Report

Doreen Amstutz Doreen E Amstutz , Age 68

Lives at 355 Lane 301 Barton Lk, Fremont, IN 46737-9395 Fremont IN 46737 355 Lane 301 Barton Lk
Prior addresses: 205 E Bailey St E, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey St E Po Box 698, Payne, OH 45880-0698 Payne OH 45880 Po Box 698 Po Box 447, Payne, OH 45880-0447 Payne OH 45880 Po Box 447
Relatives: Dennis Amstutz, April Litzenberg, Rodney Miller, April Miller, Beverly Amstutz, Charie Peters, Cynthia Shafer, Emerson Litzenberg, Eric Amstutz
View Report

Jarrett Hornish Jarrett Allen Hornish , Age 22

Lives at 23373 Road 140, Oakwood, OH 45873-9307 Oakwood OH 45873 23373 Road 140
Prior addresses: 205 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey St 116 S Maple ST, Payne, OH 45880-9499 Payne OH 45880 116 S Maple ST 23035 Road 140, Oakwood, OH 45873-9307 Oakwood OH 45873 23035 Road 140
Relatives: Abby Hornish, Alexa Hornish, Bradley Hornish, Brenda Hornish, Brendan Hornish, Daniel Hornish, Dorothy Hornish, Kacy Hornish, Kevin A
View Report

Zachary Mansfield Zachary Allen Mansfield , Age 31

Lives at 320 W Oak St, Payne, OH 45880-9482 Payne OH 45880 320 W Oak St
Prior addresses: Po Box 673, Payne, OH 45880-0673 Payne OH 45880 Po Box 673 5059 Township Road 128, Edison, OH 43320-9753 Edison OH 43320 5059 Township Road 128 205 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey St
Relatives: Kimberly Mansfield, Adrean Mansfield, Nicholas Mansfield, Stanley Mansfield, Beth Ross, Brooke Mansfield, Harold Ross, Isaiah Ross, Jamie Mansfield
View Report

Dennis Amstutz Dennis Michael Amstutz , Age 64

Lives at 355 Lane 301 Barton Lk, Fremont, IN 46737-9395 Fremont IN 46737 355 Lane 301 Barton Lk
Prior addresses: 205 E Bailey ST, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey ST 335 Lane 301 Barton Lk, Fremont, IN 46737-9395 Fremont IN 46737 335 Lane 301 Barton Lk 304 N Main St, Payne, OH 45880-9078 Payne OH 45880 304 N Main St
Relatives: Doreen Amstutz, Beverly Amstutz, Eric Amstutz, Jeanise Amstutz, John Amstutz, Joseph Amstutz, Melissa Amstutz, April Litzenberg, Austin Amstutz
View Report

Roxie Carroll Roxie Marie Carroll , Age 65

Lives at 711 E Main St, Van Wert, OH 45891-1852 Van Wert OH 45891 711 E Main St
Prior addresses: 205 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey St
Relatives: Barry Carroll, Beth Thomas, Billy Carroll, Brenda Schmidt, Dana Darst, Dawn Gehle, Dianna Girardot, Dwain Darst
View Report

Marianne Case Marianne B Case , Age 97

Lives at 205 E Bailey St E, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey St E
Prior addresses: Po Box 495, Payne, OH 45880-0495 Payne OH 45880 Po Box 495 205 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880-9061 Payne OH 45880 205 E Bailey St 426 N Maple St, Payne, OH 45880-9022 Payne OH 45880 426 N Maple St
Relatives: James Case, Jeffrey Case, Hannah Case, Katherine Case, Katherine Fischer, Rebecca Case, Amanda Patterson, Betty Leiker, Brian Patterson
View Report


Neighbors

Laura St
Payne, OH
View Property Report
209 E Bailey St
Payne, OH
View Property Report
202 N Laura St
Payne, OH
View Property Report
Bailey St
Payne, OH
View Property Report

FAQs

Who lives at 205 E Bailey St, Payne, OH 45880?
According to our records, the current person living in 205 E Bailey St is Stacey Carroll.
Is this property currently for sale?
The property is not for sale and last sold for $35,725 on Apr 11, 2025. Use USPhoneBook to review nearby listings or compare similar homes in the area.
What is the estimated value of this property?
The estimated value is $168,000, reflecting a 10% change over the past year. You can explore price history and tax records to see how the value has changed over time.
How big is this property?
It features approximately 1,590 sq ft of living space on a 5,837 sq ft lot, built in 1967 and classified as a Single Family.
What nearby properties can I compare this to?
Nearby homes include Laura St, 209 E Bailey St, and 202 N Laura St, each with its own property report to help compare size, value, and residents.